Right now, I am teaching about Columbus in my U.S. History Class. We are discussing the difference between the true story of Columbus (one filled with slavery, murder, and oppression) and the heroified version that he has often been presented as in both U.S. History and Latin American History overall. Columbus is somewhat of an extreme example; however, the problem of heroification does not stop with such a clear contradiction like Columbus, but extends to many other historical heroes as well.
If you are a conservative than Ronald Reagan is probably one of your heroes. However, in the midst of applauding his famous speech at the Berlin Wall and his strong leadership, people may overlook the direct dishonesty of the Iran-Contra Scandal, how he brought the U.S. into a huge deficit, and his support of very undemocratic regimes in Latin America. On the other hand, liberals may have a tendency to make a hero out of someone like FDR. While FDR did do some great things in the nation and helped many Americans during the time of Great Depression, we cannot forget about the Japanese internment camps or his attempts to undermine the separation of powers by trying to add seats to the Supreme Court. It is important that we don’t even deify men like Gandhi or Martin Luther King. While they were amazing men, and their non-violence resistance should be applauded by all, we have to remember the shortcomings of Gandhi in his relationship with his own wife and Dr. King’s adulterous actions.
Why is heroifying leaders so dangerous? For one, it does not give us a true view of history. Making Columbus a hero mocks the plight of the Native Americans who were enslaved and killed under his rule. Making Reagan or Roosevelt blameless undermines the stories of the people that were hurt by their administration’s decisions. Understanding the faults of our heroes, even great men like Martin Luther King, is extremely important. We realize that all are human and that we all put up a façade at times. When we make these men out to be saints, we put them on a different plane than us; therefore, undermining our own potential to do great things. When anyone talks about the greatness of anyone, it always needs to be taken with a grain salt. There are great examples we can look up to, but let’s not fall into the trap of heroifying people whether they are like Columbus and don’t deserve the honor at all, FDR and Reagan which deserve praise to an extent, or are like Gandhi and Dr. King which we can learn extraordinary things from without deifying them as individuals. In the end, the great heroes are people like us- a mixture of right and wrong, good and evil.